MediaMonkey forum

There was no bug assigned to that issue, I don't really have a problem with using the same icon for both.

It is mentioned by rusty in the ticket:

rusty wrote:a) Stephen, Dreadm:
-Can you update the Edit Properties icon ?

And I agree it needs update and I provided a replacement icon with a download link.

nohitter151 wrote:I don't really have a problem with using the same icon for both.

Well, I do have a problem with that.

There is no similarity between "statistics" and "collections" icons.

Right now "edit collection" use an icon that doesn't represent the function.
Which is a basic requirement for any program interface!

He meant update it because it looked bad (eg outdated/antialiasing issues).

Anyway I think my icon fits well enough for both.

I'm not following you.
So my statistic icon looks outdated and aliased?
It has the same gradient/style/borders/anti-aliasing/shadow than any other icons in the pulse set.

Are you sure that's what he meant?

Dreadlau wrote:I'm not following you.
So my statistic icon looks outdated and aliased?
It has the same gradient/style/borders/anti-aliasing/shadow than any other icons in the pulse set.

Are you sure that's what he meant?

He said mine was outdated and yours looked bad (not antialiased) in the older build. You even showed that in the first post of this thread. http://www.mediamonkey.com/forum/viewto ... 76#p288331

And yes, I'm sure. I exchanged emails with him about it.

Anyways if you think we need a new icon, we should open a new bug for it. But I don't really see that it's necessary. Even your icon works for both locations (the notepad one).

So to be clear. Does the design of the "notepad" icon look bad?
Or was it because of the anti-aliasing rendering issue I reported in this thread. And it looks ok now?

As for the different icon. I think it's worth to be reported. A collection and a statistic/text file is two different things.

Dreadlau wrote:...because of the anti-aliasing rendering issue I reported in this thread. And it looks ok now?

Yes.

1363 pulse skin: the icon in front of "Scan continuously"
and the one in front of "Scan at startup" are not rendered correctly.


Could someone reopen the ticket with this new information?

Thank you.

Are you sure your screenshot is from 1363 ? I've tried PTBR with latest build and there's much more space for checkboxes than in your shots.
Also what icons problem ? I don't see any difference between them.

That's because I used a screenshot from gege of a previous build.

But the problem is still in 1363. The icons looks aliased because the alpha channel is broken.
It's the same issue that happened with the other icons in this thread. But I didn't notice that it was broken in that particular dialog till now.

Problem still present in 1365

I can't see any problem with Pulse skin ... can you give me any screenshot with a description what's wrong ?

PetrCBR wrote:I can't see any problem with Pulse skin ... can you give me any screenshot with a description what's wrong ?

HI Petr,

Here it is. ( Icons on the right side shows correct. )

Fixed in 1368.