Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

Post a reply

Smilies
:D :) :( :o :-? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :roll: :wink:

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by chrisjj » Sat Nov 14, 2009 8:23 pm

Thanks NH.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by nohitter151 » Sat Nov 14, 2009 7:31 pm

Yep that seems to be it. I imagine though that since the plugin can encode and decode, that both fees would apply.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by chrisjj » Sat Nov 14, 2009 7:16 pm

Aha, thanks, so is this the cost referred to?
Encoder/Codec Products
Per Unit Fee $0.98

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by nohitter151 » Sat Nov 14, 2009 5:38 pm

chrisjj wrote: Is this the cost referred to?
. . . . . . . Decoder Products
Per Unit Fee $0.48
No, that is for the decoder but MM's is an encoder.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by GeraldB » Sat Nov 14, 2009 5:33 pm

I'm one who doesn't need it, so would prefer not to pay extra. It would be good if there could be some sensing of users' preference before increasing the cost of MM.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by pk1234 » Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:18 am

rovingcowboy wrote:okay so in my example its 5,000 gold users times .48 equals $2400.00 for them to have it for free.

5,000 times 30.00 equals 150,000.00 so they could pay with that. how ever !! including it in the program will also be in the free program which brings us back to the 15,000 downloads and the possible price of over 120 dollar price for monkey. do you really want that inculded now with the program for the gold users. :o

:oops: made a math mistake on the first post fixed it. :)
Don't you earn money when people buy MM-Gold?
15 Euros and there is no money to implement an AAC Encoder in the Gold version?

...

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by rovingcowboy » Wed Jul 08, 2009 11:27 pm

chrisjj wrote:> how ever !! including it in the program will also be in the free program

There are about a dozen features included in the paid (Gold) version and not the free version. The OP is simply asking why this encoder is not one of them.
yep but what you dont see i am saying, is they are disabled in the free version. which is cause enough for the plugin owner to claim it is also a unit and needs paid for. 8)

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by arthurb » Wed Jul 08, 2009 6:53 pm

I too am confused by this issue. I would have thought that it would be possible to only pay the licence fee for the registered 'Gold' users, but, of course, I am not familiar with the actual terms of the licence. I also use dbPoweramp, and they use a Nero decoder which you have to download separately from the Nero a.g. web-site, but it is free. When you unzip the file, there appears to be both an encoder and a decoder; would it not be possible to use Nero's free offerings?

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by chrisjj » Wed Jul 08, 2009 12:38 pm

> how ever !! including it in the program will also be in the free program

There are about a dozen features included in the paid (Gold) version and not the free version. The OP is simply asking why this encoder is not one of them.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by rovingcowboy » Wed Jul 08, 2009 12:21 pm

okay so in my example its 5,000 gold users times .48 equals $2400.00 for them to have it for free.

5,000 times 30.00 equals 150,000.00 so they could pay with that. how ever !! including it in the program will also be in the free program which brings us back to the 15,000 downloads and the possible price of over 120 dollar price for monkey. do you really want that inculded now with the program for the gold users. :o

:oops: made a math mistake on the first post fixed it. :)

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by chrisjj » Wed Jul 08, 2009 12:14 pm

> cause it says per unit. meaning that each download of monkey having it in there would be considered one unit.

The OP question is not about the free version, but about the Gold version:

>> I wondered, that it is not free for the owners of MediaMonkey Gold...
>> I just bought MM, and it doesn't own an included aac encoder?

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by rovingcowboy » Wed Jul 08, 2009 11:47 am

chrisjj wrote:> it was preferable to most to charge a small add-on fee, to raising the cost of MediaMonkey
> to cover aac licensing liabilities (see: http://www.vialicensing.com/licensing/AAC_fees.cfm )

Is this the cost referred to?
. . . . . . . Decoder Products
Per Unit Fee $0.48
if it is chris that makes since.

cause it says per unit. meaning that each download of monkey having it in there would be considered one unit.
how many people have mediamonkey? how many times 48 do you need to do to find that cost per unit?
say there is around 10,000 users of mediamonkey that downloaded the free version and then half of them got the gold version. so thats 15,000 downloaded units. times .48 equals $7200.00, do you really think rusty and jiri are going to be able to pay that with a cheap 30 dollar cost for the program? :o i don't think so more likely they would need to charge upwards of over $120.00 dollars for the monkey just to cover the cost of the free downloaded versions :(
Edited in

and yes that is how per unit is done in software.

its the same with m$ wanting to make you buy a new cdrom for each
computer to put the same os on different computers. which is what they do.

second edited in
okay so my math was slightly off.

okay on the price it seems that they sould be able to handle it if every one of the 15000 paid 30 for monkey it would make them.
450,000.00
but if only the 5000 paid 30 for it. then it would make them 150,000.00

so they still would make 142,800.00 profit not as much a loss as i thought it was.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by Santa » Wed Jul 08, 2009 12:08 am

Has any thought been given to revising this policy? I'd be happy to buy MM Gold if it included AAC encoding. Although it would make your packaging harder, you could do an unlimited MP3 or AAC choice?

Maybe I'm an irrational guy, but for some reason there's a big difference in my head between $20 and $30.

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by chrisjj » Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:26 am

> it was preferable to most to charge a small add-on fee, to raising the cost of MediaMonkey
> to cover aac licensing liabilities (see: http://www.vialicensing.com/licensing/AAC_fees.cfm )

Is this the cost referred to?
. . . . . . . Decoder Products
Per Unit Fee $0.48

Re: Why does "AAC Encoder Plug-in" cost money?

by pk1234 » Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:01 am

Is there a trick to use an AAC-Encoder from Quicktime or others im MM so I dont have to pay the Lic-Fees?

Top