[quote=Barry4679 post_id=508128 time=1680617420 user_id=28275]
My view is that a View, that is created by Manage Views facility, should only be changeable by the Manage Views facility.
ie. you could use a View, and make running changes to sort sequence, or columns displayed or whatever, but those changes were temporary, and NOT saved to the View definition. The next time that you switched that View, it should be re-initialised to whatever you last set using the Manage View facility.
It would also be useful if the Manage View facility had an option to persist the current (temporary) View setup by overwriting the existing specification
[/quote]
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Anyone DISagree with the above suggestions? Either way is fine for me

1) Persistent sort order in custom view with option to update from current view ie save current config over previous.

2) Changeable custom view as exists now, with option to LOCK the associated sort order, and/or all other aspects of the view.

[quote=Panchdara post_id=507912 time=1680006361 user_id=76533]
I accidentally clicked on a column header and it sorted by that column.... ok I understand).
I like to have my listing by Artist/Album/Track#... is there a easy wat to keep this as a default and revert easily if the sort is changed (accidentally in my case)??
[/quote]

Hi Panchdara,
as discussed above there is no way to lock the specification for a view, which is a pain.
But it is relatively easy to get back to your Artist/Album/Track# sort preference.
Maybe you already understand the following, but I used MM for many years before someone described the following to me.
You can easing set up a multi-tag sort sequence by using control clicks on the secondary column headers
To achieve your sequence you would:
[list][*] click the Artist column header
[*] and then ctrl+click the Album and then Track # column headings.[/list]


[quote=Rob_S post_id=508099 time=1680538586 user_id=112670]
OK, if that is how it is meant to work, would you consider a feature request for option to lock the selected sort order for a custom view?
I think it would be very useful to be able to re-open my view and always have it appear in the same sort order, no matter what I did once in that view the last time.
Particularly since I might want to use that view in different nodes just to have the column configuration but sometimes with different sort orders.
[/quote]

Regardless of what LowLander said, I seriously doubt that it was "designed" to work as it does.
My guess is that it was designed better, but they run out of time to complete whatever was designed.
I remember the pre-release beta. There was something that seemed to allow management of Custom Views, including where they should be offered. It wasn't coming together well, and got pulled before release.

Hopefully enhancement is in the plan for release 5.1

My view is that a View, that is created by Manage Views facility, should only be changeable by the Manage Views facility.
ie. you could use a View, and make running changes to sort sequence, or columns displayed or whatever, but those changes were temporary, and NOT saved to the View definition. The next time that you switched that View, it should be re-initialised to whatever you last set using the Manage View facility.
It would also be useful if the Manage View facility had an option to persist the current (temporary) View setup by overwriting the existing specification

OK, if that is how it is meant to work, would you consider a feature request for option to lock the selected sort order for a custom view?

I think it would be very useful to be able to re-open my view and always have it appear in the same sort order, no matter what I did once in that view the last time.

Particularly since I might want to use that view in different nodes just to have the column configuration but sometimes with different sort orders.

Changing sort modifies the setting. You can either do this in the View setting or directly in the Filelisting.

So even if I have saved my custom view with a specific multi-field sort sort order, when I reload my custom view, by design, it reverts to the last used sort order?

In that case, what is the purpose of being able to define a sort order for a custom view?? What am I missing here?

I think this should be seen as a bug. Or one should have the option to prioritize the sort order of the custom view to override existing????

Or a separate option to save a custom sort.....

Last sort is used. So if a different sort is applied, it will continue to be used. This is by design.

I was going to suggest saving a custom view with your desired sort order, and then reloading that as needed.

However, I just tried to edit the sort order in my favorite list, and it would no stick, so I am not sure now if this is working as it should.

Can somebody else try that and see if it works for them?

Under "Manage views" edit your saved views, change the sort order using a multi-level sort, OK, and OK, and then see if it take effect.

Hi. I like the LIST view when using MM. (Just like MM4)

I accidentally clicked on a column header and it sorted by that column.... ok I understand).

I like to have my listing by Artist/Album/Track#... is there a easy wat to keep this as a default and revert easily if the sort is changed (accidentally in my case)??

Thanks