by ChoppedBroccoli » Thu Jan 09, 2025 3:16 pm
This is actually a follow up to a related smart playlist MMA feature request from 2016:
https://mediamonkey.com/forum/viewtopic ... 07#p425007
I've noticed I've basically been creating a ton of smart playlists in MMW to cover all my possible listening moods in MMA. For example, I may want to listen to 3 star and up Rock music from the 90s in MMA. I have Rock Smart playlist in MMW, then I create further refined nested playlists in MMW (2 star rock, 3 star rock, 4 star rock, 3 star 90s rock, etc). As you can see, just one genre listening preference explodes into 4+ playlists just to cover some listening scenarios in MMA.
Currently I have like 100 smart playlists in MMW, nested 3 levels deep to keep some cleanliness, just to cover some listening moods in MMA which seems crazy to me.
The holy grail for me would still be to have dynamic smart playlist generation in MMA, and then tie it into voice prompts. I would love to tell the Google Assistant in my car "play rock and rap songs from the 1990s that are rated above 2 stars in Media Monkey" and have that start playing in my car stereo. Perhaps that type of functionality is far away? To be honest when I mentioned this 8 years ago, I figured we'd be there by now by some combination of improvements in the Google Voice assistant and MMA.
Now I am hoping that perhaps there are smaller features in MMA that achieve 80% of this and improve the on the go listening experience.
TLDR: could we add a dynamic quick picker at the top of a playlist or now playing queue in MMA to refine the existing list? For example, If I transfer a MMW smart playlist that is 3 stars and above into MMA, when I go to the view the playlist it would be awesome if I got "quick pick" (say a hide-able, horizontal picker) options to refine the playlist based on some basic things like a set of genre(s), year(s), etc? It would be awesome if the "quick picker" was only populated with options that exist in the current playlist/queue (for example the genres listed would only list "rock" and "alternative" since those are the only genres in the current queue). This would greatly reduce the number of smart playlists I need to send over to MMA.
I suppose you'd have to implement the smart playlist feature anyway in MMA to achieve this? But even so, a quick picker/refinement bar in almost all views, would still be an awesome way to quickly refine a set of music for my current mood and remove the need to build out a MMA UI for creating smart playlists from scratch with conditional logic etc like in MMW (the mobile UI for this wouldn't be so straightforward).
What I need is to be able to quickly refine on a set of tags (years, rating, genres, tempo, mood, etc) that already list all the possible/likely options and just require a few fat finger presses to select them.
I experimented with Symfonium, and while it has something along these lines, it didn't quite work as seamlessly as I hoped so didn't end up switching
Some brainstorming here:
https://support.symfonium.app/t/smart-filters/326

This is actually a follow up to a related smart playlist MMA feature request from 2016: https://mediamonkey.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=425007#p425007
I've noticed I've basically been creating a ton of smart playlists in MMW to cover all my possible listening moods in MMA. For example, I may want to listen to 3 star and up Rock music from the 90s in MMA. I have Rock Smart playlist in MMW, then I create further refined nested playlists in MMW (2 star rock, 3 star rock, 4 star rock, 3 star 90s rock, etc). As you can see, just one genre listening preference explodes into 4+ playlists just to cover some listening scenarios in MMA.[b] Currently I have like 100 smart playlists in MMW, nested 3 levels deep to keep some cleanliness, just to cover some listening moods in MMA which seems crazy to me.
[/b]
The holy grail for me would still be to have dynamic smart playlist generation in MMA, and then tie it into voice prompts. I would love to tell the Google Assistant in my car "play rock and rap songs from the 1990s that are rated above 2 stars in Media Monkey" and have that start playing in my car stereo. Perhaps that type of functionality is far away? To be honest when I mentioned this 8 years ago, I figured we'd be there by now by some combination of improvements in the Google Voice assistant and MMA.
Now I am hoping that perhaps there are smaller features in MMA that achieve 80% of this and improve the on the go listening experience.
[b]TLDR: could we add a dynamic quick picker at the top of a playlist or now playing queue in MMA to refine the existing list?[/b] For example, If I transfer a MMW smart playlist that is 3 stars and above into MMA, when I go to the view the playlist it would be awesome if I got "quick pick" (say a hide-able, horizontal picker) options to refine the playlist based on some basic things like a set of genre(s), year(s), etc? It would be awesome if the "quick picker" was only populated with options that exist in the current playlist/queue (for example the genres listed would only list "rock" and "alternative" since those are the only genres in the current queue). This would greatly reduce the number of smart playlists I need to send over to MMA.
I suppose you'd have to implement the smart playlist feature anyway in MMA to achieve this? But even so, a quick picker/refinement bar in almost all views, would still be an awesome way to quickly refine a set of music for my current mood and remove the need to build out a MMA UI for creating smart playlists from scratch with conditional logic etc like in MMW (the mobile UI for this wouldn't be so straightforward).
What I need is to be able to quickly refine on a set of tags (years, rating, genres, tempo, mood, etc) that already list all the possible/likely options and just require a few fat finger presses to select them.
I experimented with Symfonium, and while it has something along these lines, it didn't quite work as seamlessly as I hoped so didn't end up switching
Some brainstorming here: https://support.symfonium.app/t/smart-filters/326
[img]https://support.symfonium.app/uploads/default/original/1X/7956d3f9e87ae82c6da207c7789ac9581d5ea1f4.png[/img]
[img]https://support.symfonium.app/uploads/default/original/1X/abf063f15eeb53273b08d144995048606b36c016.jpeg[/img]