by BigInJapan » Fri May 03, 2013 10:25 am
There seems to be something of a paradigm in Android media players to have a basic split between the content browsing functions and the player functions, and the Now Playing list seems to be considered a component of the player rather than its own thing.
In Play Music, to see Now Playing, you navigate to the player first and then tap an icon to switch the middle section of the screen between the album art and the np list.
In BeyondPod, to see Now Playing, you navigate to the player first and then pull the np list down window shade style over top of artwork.
I've removed my other players lately to force myself to focus on MMA, but I seem to remember others having a similar approach.
Coming from MM desktop, this feels counter-intuitive. On the desktop, we access the Now Playing list in the same part of the interface where we access the Artist/Album/Genre browsers, the playlists, or whatever else. However, I like the idea of keeping MMA consistent with Android's design queues, so my vote would go toward not putting Now Playing on the main screen and leaving it something that can only be accessed through the player. I think there's a lot room for improvement in the visual design of how the Now Playing list is pulled up from within the player, but I think in Android, that's where it should be accessed from.
(Or, at least, that's what I think today.)
There seems to be something of a paradigm in Android media players to have a basic split between the content browsing functions and the player functions, and the Now Playing list seems to be considered a component of the player rather than its own thing.
In Play Music, to see Now Playing, you navigate to the player first and then tap an icon to switch the middle section of the screen between the album art and the np list.
In BeyondPod, to see Now Playing, you navigate to the player first and then pull the np list down window shade style over top of artwork.
I've removed my other players lately to force myself to focus on MMA, but I seem to remember others having a similar approach.
Coming from MM desktop, this feels counter-intuitive. On the desktop, we access the Now Playing list in the same part of the interface where we access the Artist/Album/Genre browsers, the playlists, or whatever else. However, I like the idea of keeping MMA consistent with Android's design queues, so my vote would go toward not putting Now Playing on the main screen and leaving it something that can only be accessed through the player. I think there's a lot room for improvement in the visual design of how the Now Playing list is pulled up from within the player, but I think in Android, that's where it should be accessed from.
(Or, at least, that's what I think today.)