Error Ripping

[dannyno]

I've not had this problem, but these seem to refer to the same issue:

http://www.ventismedia.com/mantis/view.php?id=3613

http://www.ventismedia.com/mantis/view.php?id=6194


Dan

[nohitter151]

I've not had this problem, but these seem to refer to the same issue:

http://www.ventismedia.com/mantis/view.php?id=3613

http://www.ventismedia.com/mantis/view.php?id=6194


Dan

They're also both marked as already fixed.

[yukiolele@gmail.com]

Hello! I am experiencing the same problem. I, too, purchased the GOLD edition last month and am having problems with the last track ripping correctly. I am saving as .wav files, but the problem previously described (where the end of the track is silent and then has a short bit of material at the end) is the same for me. These are regular audio CDs I am ripping and not enhanced or fancy in any way. The problem happens on about half the discs I try to rip. If the last track fails to rip properly, it does no good to try to re-rip the offending track, it fails every time. I hope this can get fixed soon. I got a first shock at listening to this error on a disc that has a very emotional last track. The music was hitting me hard and then stopped abruptly as the last ten seconds of the song were chopped off leaving me hanging there. Not good.

[yukiolele@gmail.com]

Okay, I have something to share on this issue. I have been ripping in SECURE MODE. If MM fails to rip the last track correctly (the blank or jumbled stuff at the end of the final track) I have been able to drive around the problem by re-inserting the disc, de-selecting the tracks to rip, selecting only the final track to be ripped, then changing from SECURE MODE to STANDARD MODE. I then re-rip and over-write the bad track. It has been working evey time. So, I think the problem is in the Secure Read Mode. For now, do as I did, or just rip everything in standard mode. Cheers! Yukio

[dj_intrepid]

Okay, I have something to share on this issue. I have been ripping in SECURE MODE. If MM fails to rip the last track correctly (the blank or jumbled stuff at the end of the final track) I have been able to drive around the problem by re-inserting the disc, de-selecting the tracks to rip, selecting only the final track to be ripped, then changing from SECURE MODE to STANDARD MODE. I then re-rip and over-write the bad track. It has been working evey time. So, I think the problem is in the Secure Read Mode. For now, do as I did, or just rip everything in standard mode. Cheers! Yukio

I just started using the free version and have the same issue using Secure Mode. The last track on every CD I've ripped has had an error. One even had an additional track with an error that I couldn't get to work until I used the Jitter Free mode. What a pain in the ass. I may have to use another program now. It's a good thing I didn't pay for the program.

[nohitter151]

I just started using the free version and have the same issue using Secure Mode. The last track on every CD I've ripped has had an error. One even had an additional track with an error that I couldn't get to work until I used the Jitter Free mode. What a pain in the ass. I may have to use another program now. It's a good thing I didn't pay for the program.

Could you clarify what you mean by "has had an error"? Just because the pop-up screen says "error" doesn't necessarily mean there was a problem with the rip. It just means the CRC didn't match exactly from your rip to the AccurateRip database, but that could be for loads of reasons other than a bad rip (different CD pressing, etc.). Now, if you mean the track doesn't rip at all or has bad/missing sound, that's a different story. But please be clear about the actual problem.

[Ludek]

There was indeed a bug in secure mode when ripping the last CD track.

It is fixed as http://www.ventismedia.com/mantis/view.php?id=9710 in build 1601.

Until that build is available I would recommend to use the default 'standard read' when ripping.

[Lowlander]

This should be fixed in MediaMonkey 4.0.7.1503, please confirm: http://www.mediamonkey.com/forum/viewto ... 30#p348130

[pacific]

I had a similar issue with the end of the track not being ripped correctly. I fixed it by:

- changing from secure to standard read.
- turning off 'on the fly' encoding.
- turning on 'verify ripped tracks'.

I did all that at once so I don't know which settings are necessary/sufficient to fix the problem, but I hope that trying the same thing helps someone.

[nohitter151]

I had a similar issue with the end of the track not being ripped correctly. I fixed it by:

- changing from secure to standard read.
- turning off 'on the fly' encoding.
- turning on 'verify ripped tracks'.

I did all that at once so I don't know which settings are necessary/sufficient to fix the problem, but I hope that trying the same thing helps someone.

There's a known bug in secure mode when ripping the last track of an album.

It has been fixed in the latest beta build, which is available for download in the beta-testing section of the forum.

[rom]

same problem here!! are the tech support guys looking at this problem?

[Lowlander]

are the tech support guys looking at this problem?

Did you try MediaMonkey 4.0.7.1506: http://www.mediamonkey.com/forum/viewto ... 91#p349291

Because if it happens with that version a debug log (step 4b) will be needed with the debug version of it: http://www.mediamonkey.com/forum/viewto ... ?f=6&t=341

[cnapan]

I have the same problem others are reporting. One or two tracks fail to rip in Secure mode, but happily work in standard mode.

I can confirm the problem still persists in 4.0.7.1506, which I just ran in debug mode, and captured the debug log (see below).

I always assumed the problem was my cd drive, but from reading this thread it seems not.

I'm using Dell Precision T1500 Windows 7 64 bit, with SP1, i7 intel 860@2.8GHz, and the CD drive is: RW HL-DT-ST DVD+- GH50N.

To help track the problem I captured the debug logging while ripping a single track which I know always produces the error. Here's the result below. I've removed all the duplicate events, so if you see a break in the event numbers, it means the event at the start of the break is repeated (the number of times indicated by the size of the jump in the numbering... if that makes sense).

The debug session captures the period from when I start the rip till the error message appears at the end.

I hope you get this fixed. I didn't pay attention to the errors for ages because the tracks appeared to have been ripped, but then when you listen to it, there are problems - often at the end, but I wouldn't want to say precisely how the track is broken.

Code: Select all

00027445	47.79082108	[6256] FLAC: Main loop starting.
00028342	49.29759598	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00029486	51.28553009	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=149292, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=149292, len=2097984]
00029487	51.28725815	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00030028	52.22949982	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=150184, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00030029	52.23051453	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00032383	56.09427261	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00032387	56.28781128	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00032888	57.03170395	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=151968, num=892], [tOver: start=151968, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00032889	57.03274155	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00034035	59.01425934	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00034043	59.02297211	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=152860, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=152860, len=2097984]
00034044	59.02382660	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00034548	59.94970703	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=153752, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00035083	60.89398956	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=153752, num=892], [tOver: start=153752, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00035084	60.89495087	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00037934	65.64172363	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=155536, num=892], [tOver: start=155536, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=156428, len=2097984]
00037935	65.64268494	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00038536	66.67864227	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00038545	66.68738556	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=156428, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=156428, len=2097984]
00038546	66.68822479	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00039577	68.54349518	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=157320, num=892], [tOver: start=157320, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00039578	68.54456329	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00041842	72.51254272	[6256] Winamp sim - ignoring.
00042379	73.26293182	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=159104, num=892], [tOver: start=159104, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=159996, len=2097984]
00042380	73.26381683	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00042968	74.28064728	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00042969	74.28227997	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00043468	75.20226288	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00043477	75.21093750	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=160888, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00043478	75.21183777	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00043921	76.06581116	[6256] Thread 'UpdateDriveLetters_Var'has finished 6468
00043985	76.13128662	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=160888, num=892], [tOver: start=160888, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00043986	76.13225555	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00045173	78.15706635	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00045719	79.10894775	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00046273	79.90770721	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=162672, num=892], [tOver: start=162672, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00046274	79.90858459	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00047357	81.83744812	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=163564, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=163564, len=2097984]
00047358	81.83911133	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00047853	82.75308990	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00047862	82.76159668	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=164456, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00047863	82.76252747	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00050053	86.50937653	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00050061	86.72033691	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00051014	88.32493591	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=166240, num=892], [tOver: start=166240, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=167132, len=2097984]
00051015	88.32595825	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00051608	89.33502197	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00051616	89.34251404	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=167132, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=167132, len=2097984]
00051617	89.34336853	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00051698	89.42044830	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00052130	90.26444244	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00052190	90.32393646	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00052733	91.27757263	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00053286	92.06070709	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=168024, num=892], [tOver: start=168024, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=168916, len=2097984]
00053287	92.06171417	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00053842	93.04798126	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00053850	93.05608368	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=168916, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=168916, len=2097984]
00053851	93.05697632	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00053911	93.30666351	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00054332	93.95075989	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=169808, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00054333	93.95206451	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00056535	97.65472412	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00056543	97.66319275	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=171592, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00056544	97.66410828	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00057005	98.56230164	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=171592, num=892], [tOver: start=171592, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00057006	98.56323242	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00058630	101.43148041	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00059215	102.43010712	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00060273	104.14688873	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00060281	104.15483093	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00060765	105.04061890	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00060774	105.04893494	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00062985	108.70616150	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=176944, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00062986	108.70774841	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00063472	109.60484314	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=176944, num=892], [tOver: start=176944, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00063473	109.60595703	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00065115	112.35913086	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00065116	112.36000061	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=178728, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00065117	112.36083221	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00065588	113.24606323	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=178728, num=892], [tOver: start=178728, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00065589	113.24703979	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00066049	114.13009644	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=178728, num=892], [tOver: start=178728, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=179620, len=2097984]
00066050	114.13114929	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00068152	117.76117706	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=180512, num=892], [tOver: start=180512, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=181404, len=2097984]
00068153	117.76223755	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00068705	118.73778534	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=181404, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=181404, len=2097984]
00068706	118.73907471	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00068795	118.82598877	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00069232	119.68296051	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00070808	122.36597443	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=183188, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=183188, len=2097984]
00070809	122.36732483	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00071278	123.24501038	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00071288	123.25386810	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00073365	126.84640503	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=185864, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=0, len=0]
00073366	126.84743500	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00074483	128.60188293	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=185864, num=892], [tOver: start=185864, len=2097984], [tOver2: start=186756, len=2097984]
00074484	128.60299683	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00075032	129.57238770	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00075039	129.58052063	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00075571	130.52635193	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00075961	131.33660889	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00077106	133.14726257	[6256] ReadAudioSec(): [t: start=188540, num=892], [tOver: start=0, len=0], [tOver2: start=188540, len=2097984]
00077107	133.14869690	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00077565	134.02615356	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00077566	134.02705383	[6256] hpCDEBurn: We are splitting the reading process into more buffers
00078021	134.89280701	[6256] Thread 'EncodeSongs_Threaded' is going to callback
00078024	134.91156006	[6256] Forms: RestoreTopMost: Starting
00078025	134.91362000	[6256] MainForm: NC Activate -
00078038	134.92897034	[6256] Forms: NormalizeTopMost: Starting
00078039	134.93270874	[6256] MainForm: NC Activate -
00078574	135.93510437	[6256] TGenThread.Create: ThreadName: UpdateDriveLetters_Var , Running Threads: Internal: 2, All: 28
00078578	135.93873596	[6256] Thread initialized 1612
00078586	135.94746399	[6256] Thread 'UpdateDriveLetters_Var'has finished 1612
00081113	140.21447754	[6256] Forms: RestoreTopMost: Starting
00081115	140.21792603	[6256] MainForm: NC Activate +
00081116	140.21949768	[6256] hpCDEBurn: Freeing device
00081117	140.22041321	[6256] Thread 'CDRead_Var'has finished 4688
00081172	140.46321106	[6256] Unlocked file: Q:\mirrored\Music\Herbert Blomstedt - San Francisco Symphony\Nielsen- The Symphonies 1-3 [Disc 1]\05 - Symphony No.2 'The Four Temperaments'- 1. Allegro collerico.flac.XXXXXX
00081351	140.65228271	[6256] 6364 DB lock finished, took 64.
00081358	140.65812683	[6256] 6364 DB lock finished, took 214.
00081479	140.97695923	[6256] MainForm: NC Activate -
00081534	141.04756165	[6256] Winamp sim - ignoring.
00081678	141.19822693	[6256] BQ: Starting a new thread.
00081689	141.20756531	[6256] TGenThread.Create: ThreadName: BackgroundQueue , Running Threads: Internal: 1, All: 27
00081692	141.21092224	[6256] 6412 DB open SQL: SELECT Songs.ID FROM Songs WHERE ( Songs.TrackType in (3) ) LIMIT 1 
00081699	141.22357178	[6256] 6412 DB lock finished, took 47.
00081700	141.22523499	[6256] New thread starting 1
00081711	141.23486328	[6256] TGenThread.Create: ThreadName:  , Running Threads: Internal: 2, All: 28
00081715	141.23852539	[6256] Thread '' is going to callback
00081716	141.23985291	[6256] Thread ''has finished 4644
00082280	142.22050476	[6256] TGenThread.Create: ThreadName: _ManageTransactions , Running Threads: Internal: 2, All: 28
00082284	142.22406006	[6256] Thread '_ManageTransactions'has finished 5844
00083418	144.23806763	[6256] Thread 'BackgroundQueue'has finished 6412
00083429	144.24729919	[6256] TGenThread.Create: ThreadName: _ManageTransactions , Running Threads: Internal: 2, All: 28
00083433	144.25080872	[6256] Thread '_ManageTransactions'has finished 7052

[nohitter151]

It should be fixed in 1508, can you confirm?

[Guest]

It should be fixed in 1508, can you confirm?

I also curious about that.