ok Now How do I undo this.

Discussion about anything that might be of interest to MediaMonkey users.

Moderator: Gurus

rovingcowboy

ok Now How do I undo this.

Post by rovingcowboy »

i did the adujst level thing to most of the songs on the computer it could not go on for all of them as the computer crashed.

but the ones it did get done are really not worth listening to in the leveling mode.

i looked on the list in the leveling colume and found the songs have been lower'ed from 0 db's to -12.85 dbs and raised from 0 db's to 3.52 dbs

the rasing is not bad but that lowering is the pits. i can not hear the songs now when they are that low. it is in my book not worth doing.

now all my songs with kicka.. bass have a wimpy chicken drum stick bang. not very good to me.

so how can i get rid of the information that was added to the song file if any was added.
rusty
Posts: 9114
Joined: Tue Apr 29, 2003 3:39 am
Location: Montreal, Canada

Volume levelling quality + editing volume coefficients

Post by rusty »

Roving cowboy, Volume Leveling doesn't change the audio characteristics of your files--it just makes the perceived volume across all files equivalent (i.e. it doesn't affect bass any more than it affects any other portion of the audio spectrum). I personally find it to be invaluable since some of my tracks have been ripped on one encoder and others on another encoder, and without volume levelling, I'm forced to continually adjust the volume knob each time a new song starts playing.

Re. editing the volume levelling values, this cannot be done in MM 2.1, but we'll add this to the to do list for 2.2 (which we've begun working on). In the meantime, this shouldn't cause you any problems--just don't enable volume leveling in the player, and the calculated volume levelling coefficients will have no effect.

-Rusty
Lowlander
Posts: 59923
Joined: Sat Sep 06, 2003 5:53 pm

Like it

Post by Lowlander »

I perceive the volume levelling as invaluable as well. That said there are some potential problems. If a song has a lot of variation in volume the avarage (or median, I don't know) is calculated and that is adjusted, this can make a song still sound soft or loud. The songs all get softer as they are levelled to 80%.
I have not noticed problems yet with sound quality, which in itself shouldn't exist as volume levelling will only adjust played volume, no change is made to the file.
The only thing I really miss is storing this value in the tags of files. So other machines can use it and hopefully other players as well. I hope a standard is developed soon.
FurAnt
Posts: 165
Joined: Thu Jul 17, 2003 3:38 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Post by FurAnt »

Lowlander,

I downloaded MP3Gain and I ran it on my entire library (recursing subdirectories). It takes a while to do the track analysis, but it stores all of the information in a log file (so once it's analyzed, it won't ever need to be analyzed again).

After that, you can apply Track Gain to the files and it will level the replay gain in the frames of the file (not the tags). This makes the volume leveling compatible with all MP3 players.

I do this so that my iPod and library have consistent volume leveling without any quality loss.

By the way, the 83dB normalized volume seems way too low for most of my music. I can get away with about 91dB with minimal clipping (if any).

Furant
Post Reply